Benefit-risk assessment is critical to the regulatory review process for life science companies and healthcare products, including drugs, biologics, and medical devices, before it is approved for use by regulatory agencies such as the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in the United States or other regulatory agencies in other countries. It involves evaluating the potential benefits of a product against its potential risks to determine whether it can be approved for use in patients.
The primary objective of the benefit-risk assessment is to ensure that the product’s benefits outweigh its risks. The assessment considers the benefits’ magnitude, duration, and risks associated with the product. Factors such as the severity and nature of the illness or condition the product is intended to treat, the availability of alternative treatments, and the population of patients who would be prescribed the product are also taken into account.
A well-executed benefit-risk assessment helps regulatory decision-making authorities make informed decisions about approving a product for marketing and use. A product with a high benefit-to-risk ratio will likely be approved for use. However, if the product’s risks outweigh its benefits or are unknown, then regulatory decision-making authorities may require additional data or impose restrictions on its use.
Ultimately, a benefit-risk assessment aims to ensure that products approved for use are safe and effective and provide a clear patient benefit. By carefully evaluating healthcare products’ potential benefits and risks, regulatory authorities can help protect public health and ensure that patients can access safe and effective treatments.
This assessment involves gathering and analyzing data from various sources, including clinical trials, pre–clinical studies, and post-market surveillance, to determine the overall safety and effectiveness of the product. The goal is to ensure that the product’s benefits of the product outweigh the risks for the intended population. This process is an essential to regulatory compliance for pharmaceutical companies, as it helps ensure that only safe and effective products are available to patients.
Benefit-risk assessment is a complex process that involves many different steps, including:
- Identifying the potential benefits and risks of a product: This step includes evaluating the results of clinical trials and other studies and considering the intended use of the product and the population it will be used in. Although every product has side effects, the pharmacological effects must outweigh the risks. Each side effect, adverse reaction, and significant event during pre-clinical and clinical trials must be investigated and provided in detail in the specific test reports and documentation.
- Gathering and analyzing data: This includes collecting data from various sources, such as clinical trials, preclinical studies, and post-market surveillance, and analyzing it to determine the overall safety and effectiveness of the product. Documenting any significant event during these stages is crucial for a complete profile of the product’s potency, strength, and safety for effective FDA assessment.
- Communicating the results: The results of the benefit-risk assessment must be communicated to regulatory agencies such as the FDA, as well as other stakeholders, including healthcare professionals and patients. Several interactions occur between the sponsors and regulatory agencies during the pre-application and application stages. Typically, a product manager is assigned during the application process that becomes the main point of contact between the FDA and the sponsor. It’s important to communicate any questions or information about the product to the FDA; this would help ensure a thorough review and approval.
- Monitoring post-approval: Even after a product is approved, the benefit-risk assessment process continues monitoring for any new safety concerns or efficacy issues that may arise once the product is on the market. Companies must adopt good pharmacovigilance practices to monitor the product’s safety while in the market, record any adverse or fatal events and inform the FDA immediately of customer complaints and investigate the causes and take corrective or preventive actions.
It is s important to note that the benefit-risk assessment process is dynamic, meaning that the assessment may change as new information becomes available. Companies must adopt an efficient quality management system (QMS) and good documentation to keep track of all changes and process controls and maintain all product and process-related documentation. Such systems can help companies adapt better to product or process changes based on the benefit-risk assessments.
Additionally, pharmaceutical companies must comply with Good Clinical Practice (GCP) guidelines set by international regulatory authorities to ensure that the data collected in the clinical trials are high quality and reliable.
Not having a benefit-risk assessment for regulatory compliance can be a significant disadvantage for life science companies, as it can lead to:
- Non-compliance with regulations: A lack of benefit-risk assessment can result in a product or process not meeting regulatory standards, leading to non-compliance and penalties. Regulated products must always be compliant with each market’s specific regulations and standards. Lack of compliance could lead to FDA issuing Warning Letters, 483s, or even suspension or withdrawal of the product from the market. These regulations are in place to ensure that the product meets the highest standards of quality, safety, and efficacy.
- Delayed product approvals: The regulatory approval process may be delayed without a thorough benefit-risk assessment. This can impact the company’s ability to bring new products to market in a timely manner without timely approval. Lack of benefit-risk assessment can also result in the rejection of an application and, ultimately, loss of time, resources, and efforts in studies for product approval. It’s essential to communicate well with regulatory agencies for sponsors to understand the requirements for product approval.
- Difficulty in justifying product claims: Without a benefit-risk assessment, it can be difficult for the company to justify the safety and efficacy of its products to regulatory bodies and the public. FDA requires thorough documentation of all the studies and reports that show that the product is safe for human use before it can be approved.
- Difficulty in identifying potential safety issues: A lack of benefit-risk assessment can make it difficult to identify potential safety issues associated with a product or process, which can lead to negative consequences for patients and the company. This could lead to withdrawing or suspending an existing product or rejecting the marketing a new product.
- Negative impact on reputation: Not having a thorough benefit-risk assessment may damage the company’s reputation and its ability to gain the trust of customers and regulators. This especially applies to products existing in the market and those not monitored for adverse events during post-approval and marketing phases. It’s crucial for companies to monitor and maintain a product as long as it is in the market, and that includes keeping track of all significant and adverse events as well as investigating product complaints and monitoring the quality over the lifecycle of the product.
In conclusion, benefit-risk assessment is an important aspect of regulatory compliance for pharmaceutical companies as it helps to ensure that only safe and effective products are made available to patients.
PSC Biotech has the regulatory expertise to help your company assess all benefits and risks related to any product, such as pharmaceuticals, medical devices, biological products, and animal products. PSC Biotech also provides expertise in any kind of regulatory process and compliance activities, such as authoring CTD Modules and maintaining project documentation. PSC can help you develop an effective strategy to generate and maintain post-approval products and help you understand key regulations and guidelines to help your product stay compliant as long as it is marketed.
With the help of PSC Software such as ACE and ACE Essentials, you can establish an effective QMS and keep track of all your regulatory and quality-related documentation and records. PSC professionals can help you navigate the regulatory process until the end and gain marketing approval for your product.
Ready to learn more about working with us?
Contact PSC Biotech to ensure your company complies with all regulatory standards!
PSC Software Solutions
PSC Biotech Services provide fast, budget-friendly, high-level expertise.
Share, Engage, Stay Current
Deviations from standard procedures can greatly impact quality and compliance in life science facilities and the pharmaceutical industry. This blog explores best practices for identifying, investigating, and documenting deviations. It covers determining common causes,...
Quality assurance (QA) is a process that helps a business ensure its products or services meet the quality standards set by the company or its regulatory requirements. QA is involved in all stages of a product’s development, from raw material delivery through...
The BIO International Convention is the premier event for the global biotechnology industry, where you can network with thousands of peers, leaders, and partners and discover the latest innovations and opportunities in the life science sector. This year, the...